MobyGames vs Metacritic : Which is Better?

MobyGames icon

MobyGames

MobyGames is a website which catalogs video games both past and present.

License: Free

Categories: Games

Apps available for Online

VS
VS
Metacritic icon

Metacritic

Metacritic is a website that aggregates reviews of media products: music albums, games, movies, TV shows, DVDs, and formerly, books. Developed by CBS Interactive Inc.

License: Free

Categories: Games Video & Movies

Apps available for Online

MobyGames VS Metacritic

MobyGames focuses on providing a comprehensive database of video games with detailed credits and user-generated content, while Metacritic aggregates critic and user scores across various media, including video games, movies, and music. MobyGames is ideal for enthusiasts seeking in-depth game information, while Metacritic is better for quick assessments of overall media quality through aggregated scores.

MobyGames

Pros:

  • Comprehensive database of video games across various platforms
  • User-generated content and reviews
  • Detailed game credits and development history
  • Ability to filter games by various criteria (platform, genre, etc.)
  • Strong community engagement with forums and discussions

Cons:

  • Limited to video games only; no coverage for movies or other media
  • User interface can feel dated and cluttered
  • Less focus on critical reviews and scores

Metacritic

Pros:

  • Aggregated critic and user scores for games
  • Wide range of media coverage and reviews
  • User-friendly interface with easy navigation
  • Supports multiple platforms including movies and music
  • Detailed review summaries from critics

Cons:

  • Scores may not reflect the quality of the game for all audiences
  • User reviews can be biased or lack depth
  • Limited coverage of niche or indie games

Compare MobyGames